"BEYOND BORDERS" movie, fact or fiction?

Submitted by JCarson on November 10, 2006 - 2:42am.

Hi everyone,
I am analyzing the movie "Beyond Borders" (Angelina Jolie and Clive Owen) to see how real it depicts actual events. The film has been criticized for dangering lives of aid workers due to it's scenes showing a doctor involved with the CIA and gun smuggling. But the film has also been praised for raising awareness of world poverty and hunger. Kofi Annan was the host for the movie premiere but the organization "MSF" was unsupportive. Are there any doctors out there that has been to Ethiopia, Cambodia or Chechnya, or does anyone from the UNHCR have any comments, opinions? There have been many reviews from film critics, but it would be nice to hear the voice of people who have actually experienced the real thing!

Submitted by Tom Longley on November 10, 2006 - 11:40am.

I'd turn this question around and ask if there are actually any films at all about humanitarian emergency workers that do not rest their drama on the the highly questionable assumptions that relief workers are:

  1. spooks;
  2. engaging in corporate cover ups;
  3. complicit in some government scandal or another.

Are you using any other films as a counterpoint to your analysis of  this wholly rancid movie?

Submitted by JCarson on November 10, 2006 - 6:12pm.

Are there any instances in which you have encountered any illegal offers that would in return benefit your organization in funding or supplies? Are there a FEW circumstances that an aid worker has made the wrong decision in this situation? Perhaps the rare case that this has happened or an aid worker has been kidnapped is what film producers are directly focusing on? What's the truth?

Submitted by Komal Singh on November 22, 2006 - 5:55am.

Hi Tom you should watch Hotel Rwanda if you are tring to nail a movie that talks about Aid workers who are doing some genuine work, barring all the drama attached to it, it's a good flick.
I recently watched Catch the Fire, i'd really appreciate if you could recommend films about Politics in Africa.

Submitted by Tom Longley on November 22, 2006 - 12:43pm.

Hi Komal --  I have not yet seen Hotel Rwanda - it's certainly on my list. Jcarson's original question focused on how much Beyond Borders reflected reality, so I made note of equally terrible films (fiction, not documentary) about expatriate aid workers. I'd love to see a decent list of "must see" films about particular countries, focussing on political or development themes.

Lumumba or The Battle of Algiers are both intelligent films about politics in Africa. I'm sure there are many also more focussing on post-colonial themes. I mean, there's even a biopic of Franz Fanon!

Someone smarter than me chime in here ...  

Submitted by Graham Wood2 on November 10, 2006 - 3:08pm.

I have just watched 'The Constant Gardener' a film very inferior to the book. It has an interesting take on aid workers too, covering all three of Toms points above.

It seems that we either have to be deeply cynical, on the make and generally nasty or highly idealistic and innocent of the real world.

I am not sure if the film of Emma Scoggin's book 'Emma's War', an interesting, factual account of Emma McCune’s brief role in south Sudan politics, has been finished yet? But that may be an interesting one to look out for.

The aid world, though, must be faily odd from the outside and there are a few who fit these 'types' which perhaps make more interesting viewing than the vast majority of porfessional people doing their job.

Submitted by Tom Longley on November 10, 2006 - 3:42pm.

A good example of the "highly idealistic" stereotype of aid workers can be found in Sahara. In this film a WHO doctor helps solve - wait for it! - a corporate scandal that is causing a "plague" in Africa.

 

Also, according to some films, aid workers are in constant need of rescue by maverick military units. Check out Tears of the Sun, for example. Here, a "Doctors Without Borders" medic ropes a US miliary team into defeating - wait for it! - a  plot to kill off  Nigeria's ruling family.  So much for humanitarian space.

 

Don't get me started on the plot of Rambo IV, which should offend NGO security officers everywhere:

 

"... when a group of volunteer aid workers bringing supplies into Burma disappear, a relative of one of the missing missionaries begs Rambo to find them. He heads off with a small team of aspiring heroes to locate and rescue them.

 

I'm sure there are more examples.

Submitted by JCarson on November 10, 2006 - 6:01pm.

Those are some great examples, I never realized there existed other films that were also offensive to NGO's and aid workers in this respect. Beyond Borders, I believe, was the only one that received a lot of press and was surrounded by controversy (it was not even released in the UK).
Why the need to "juice" up the story plot of an aid worker in the middle of conflict and death? Are their lives and line of work too dull and boring for filmmakers and their audiences? It seems we wouldn't just be satisfied with them JUST saving peoples lives while barely securing their own.

Submitted by NEWBOB on November 19, 2006 - 10:01am.

I thought maybe we should not really be the heroes of any story. The work is about highlighting the plight populations who have no voice. INGOs media departments and the media in general often want to put forward the expat aidworker as the hero to raise the profile of the emergency and the work of INGOs and raise funds. Maybe films like "Hotel Rwanda" and "The Killing Fields" are the ones we should be watching and talking about. These give a more genuine voice and put at the centre of the story those affected by human rights violations, conflict etc.

Submitted by Tom Longley on November 22, 2006 - 12:46pm.

How about films that are not made by American or European movie studios which concern humanitarian themes?

Submitted by Komal Singh on November 22, 2006 - 5:58am.

How can we possibly strike a balance, don't you think those films have to take a stand or else the purpose of spreading a message would get defeated.

Submitted by Tom Longley on May 8, 2007 - 3:17pm.

A concerned reader emailed Aid Workers Network to let us know that Julie Benz will star as "the hot aid worker" in Rambo IV (link).

 

I despair! On the up side, howver, the movie isn't out until mid 2008, which gives us plenty of time to train our brains to ignore it.

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.